Question: What insulation is recommended when adding more?
Answer: The recommendation when adding attic insulation is always to use "unfaced" insulation. You will be putting the new insulation on top of existing insulation and you don't want a second vapor barrier in the middle of your insulation.
If there was no insulation in the attic you could install insulation with a vapor retarder and place it toward the warm side in heating climates - in your case on the bottom of the insulation in the attic. Since you have insulation in the attic, there is presumably already a vapor barrier in place under the insulation and a second one is not needed. If the ventilation is sufficient - such as with a vented soffit and full ridge vent - some counties do not require a vapor barrier under insulation in the attic if the floor is flat, i.e. not over a vaulted or cathedral ceiling.



