Jim writes from Orlando, Florida: "I live in Orlando, Fl. The current rolled insulation is practically non-existent. It has a thickness of about 1 inch. It was also installed with the kraft paper facing the attic space (non-heated side in winter). I read somewhere in humid conditions that is okay. Which would work best, to completely remove the old, decrepit insulation or just put the new in on top? And if I remove the old should I get the kind with a vapor barrier? Also, all the soffit vents in my attic have been completely closed off. The only ventilation comes from two gable vents and a solar powered fan in the center of the roof. How much of the existing wood needs to be removed to allow adequate air flow through the attic from the soffits?"
Answer: I don't recommend removing the existing insulation. It is usually better to leave it in place to avoid the work and mess of removal, keep the old insulation out of the landfill and take advantage of whatever R-value it is able to contribute. Rolling the new insulation on top of the existing insulation is fine; fill the cavity between the joists first and then run the next layer perpendicular to the first.
Check with your local building code regarding the placement of the vapor retarder. If it should be down toward the warm-in-winter side, there is so little insulation in place now that it should be OK to place new insulation on top without turning the existing insulation over.
The first layer you add should be unfaced and fill the cavity between the joists. Once the joist cavity is full you can run more insulation perpendicular to the direction of the joists. Your target total is R-49 if you have electric heating and cooling, and R-38 if you use gas, oil or a heat pump. Those are the amounts recommended by the U.S. Department of Energy for Orlando. R-49 is about 15-1/2 inches of fiberglass insulation.
Attic ventilation is an important factor in reducing heat buildup in the attic. For an unconditioned attic, air should be able to move freely through the space from the soffit to the ridge of the roof.
There is information on the Owens Corning website about ventilation. The minimum ratio is 1/300, meaning one square foot of ventilation for every 300 square feet of attic space when you have the proper balance of ridge and soffit/eave vents. We recommend a ratio of 1/150.
For a balanced system, ventilation should be equal at the under-eave and ridge. In cases where a balanced system cannot be achieved, always provide more than 50 percent of the total required ventilation at the under-eave and the remainder at the upper portion of the roof.
All openings greater than 1/8 inch must be screened to prevent insect penetration and louvered to protect against the entrance of rain and snow.